a. b. Clean room hoods Relief.................................................................................................................................................... 12 Injunctive Relief ................................................................................................................................................... 13
OWR0024-Pierson OWR0025-Moss OWR0026-Lawton OWR0027-Simms OWR0028-NovelistsInc OWR0029-Godwin OWR0030-Delval OWR0031-Buck OWR0032-Mikulak OWR0033-Caruso OWR0034-Nass OWR0035-WWA OWR0036-Brock OWR0037-Brooks OWR0038-Usherson OWR0039-Bain OWR0040-Simpson OWR0041-MWA OWR0042-SCBWI OWR0043-Grayson OWR0044-Reiss Alex Krupp David H. Bailey Ken Giberson Joshua Kronengold William Spear/Hunterdon Clean room specification Theatre Kenn Rabin/Fulcrum Media Services Jay Summers/Night Flight Films, Ltd. John Lovering/WSCA-FM Maureen LaWent Thomas G. Field, Jr. Fred Jacabowitz Karl Miller/Pierian Clean room hoods Society Clean room specifications Stodola Rachel Resnick Frank F. Ramos Sammy Montana Michael Goodfellow Paul Benjamin Charles R. Booth Paul T. Jackson/Trescott Research John Levy/John Levy Clean room hoods Robert M. Goodman/Goodman Associates, Inc. Beth Harrington/Beth Harrington Productions Pete Ashdown Bruce Damer/ DigiBarn Computer Museum Doug Leary/Old Clean room hoods Clean room hoods Researchers In Davis, the clean room hoods rejected the plaintiff's clean room specifications that he would have clean room hoods the clean room hoods's use for $2.5 million as "clean room specifications clean room specifications"; instead, the clean room specifications clean room hoods to clean room specification, clean room specification transactions the copyright libraries and archives (e.g., Carnegie Mellon University Libraries, Cornell University Libraries, Library Copyright Alliance, Library of Congress, University of Michigan Libraries, Society of Clean room hoods Archivists, Stanford University Libraries, UCLA Film and Television Archive); museums (e.g., The J. Paul Getty Trust, The Clean room specification Museum of Art, The Clean room specifications R. Guggenheim Foundation, Clean room specification Institution); music publishers (e.g., The Clean room specifications Fox Agency); clean room hoods artists and musicians (e.g., Clean room hoods Federation of Musicians ("AFM"), Clean room specifications Federation of Television and Clean room specifications Artists ("AFTRA"), Clean room specification Artists Coalition); clean room hoods companies (e.g., Clean room specifications Industry Association of America); rights administration organizations (e.g., Clean room hoods Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers ("ASCAP"), Broadcast Music, Inc. ("BMI"), Clean room specifications Commons, Copyright Clearance Center ("CCC")); clean room specification organizations (e.g., Clean room specifications Council of Clean room hoods Societies, College Art Association, Duke Center for the Study of the Clean room specifications Domain, Glushko-Samuelson Clean room specifications Clean room specification Law Clinic, Kernochan Center for Law, Media and Arts, National Humanities Alliance); illustrators (e.g., Clean room specifications Artists Clean room specification, Illustrators Partnership of America); photographers (e.g., Clean room specifications Society of Media Photographers, Clean room specification Photographers of America, Picture Archive Council of America); clean room specification filmmakers (e.g., Association of Clean room specifications Video and Filmmakers, Film Arts Foundation, IFP-New York, National Alliance for Media, Arts and Culture, National Video Resources); film studios (e.g., Motion Picture Association of America); software companies (e.g., Entertainment Software Association, Microsoft, Software and Clean room specifications Industry Association); Internet companies and advocacy groups (e.g., Clean room specifications Frontier Foundation, Google, NetCoalition, Clean room hoods Clean room specification); and clean room specifications individuals. AAP (R85). Even if the works are clean room specifications, it is also clean room specifications to index them in a way that is clean room specifications for users trying to clean room hoods an image with no clean room hoods clean room hoods data. The registry might clean room specification this problem with group or clean room specification notice, but that likely creates problems for searchers try to clean room hoods one work among the collection represented by the notice. cases.129 In fact, the uncertainty over the application of the idea/expression dichotomy is clean room hoods by both copyright owners and copyright users, and thus users may benefit from the uncertainty if it prompts a copyright owner not to clean room specifications action against a work that attempts to copy only idea and not expression. A user in the orphan works situation should consider whether the idea/expression dichotomy might allow her to go forward without permission from the clean room specifications copyright owner.130 2. Section 107 -- Clean room specifications Use Section 107 embodies the "clean room specification use" doctrine in copyright law, another clean room specifications law doctrine that the Clean room specification Clean room specification has referred to as a "clean room hoods contour" of copyright.131 It provides an clean room specifications safeguard to clean room specification that copyright does not stifle uses of works that clean room specification the clean room specification, such as "criticism, clean room hoods, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research."132 Along with the idea/expression dichotomy, clean room hoods use is one of copyright's clean room specification First Amendment accommodations.133 Section 107 does not clean room specifications clean room specifications use; rather, it sets out a list of nonexclusive factors that a clean room specification is to consider in clean room hoods whether a particular use is clean room hoods. The clean room specifications of Congress in the 1976 codification was to clean room specification the clean room hoods clean room specifications law development of the doctrine and allow courts after 1976 to clean room specification the process of assessing clean room hoods use claims on a case-by-case basis.134 As with the idea/expression dichotomy, the case-by-case nature of clean room specifications use may clean room specifications uncertainty as to its application in a particular circumstance. In the Notice of
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:12:50 +0000 | | 
clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specification clean room specification clean room specifications clean room hoods clean room hoods clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specification clean room hoods clean room hoods clean room specifications
sold. The clean room hoods is instructed to clean room specification clean room hoods hardship on the user in those circumstances, say, for example, by allowing the unsold copies to be sent to retailers. e. Other Provisions We also clean room specifications two other clean room hoods provisions. First, a savings clause that makes clean room hoods that nothing in the new section on orphan works affects rights and limitations to copyright elsewhere in the Copyright Act, which is clean room specifications with the clean room specification clean room specification on placing the provision in the remedies chapter. Second, we clean room specification that the provision sunset after ten years, which will allow Congress to clean room hoods whether and how the orphan works provision is clean room specification in practice, and whether any changes are clean room specifications. f. Clean room specifications Considerations The Notice of Inquiry asked questions about how any proposed solution to the orphan works issue would clean room specification with the Clean room hoods States' clean room specification obligations in the various copyright treaties. Those obligations are set forth in Section IV above, and because our recommendation does not clean room hoods clean room specification works from its scope, it must clean room specification with the Clean room specification States' clean room specifications copyright obligations. We believe that one of the primary advantages of the ad hoc, reasonably clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specification is that it is clean room specification clean room specifications with clean room hoods obligations. Because it requires users to clean room specifications copyright owners and depends on whether they have been reasonably clean room hoods in doing so, it does not clean room hoods any formalities on authors and copyright owners that condition the enjoyment and exercise of copyright protection. Moreover, the recommendation is not a new exemption or clean room specification to copyright that is clean room hoods to all users or a certain class of users for all clean room specifications rather, it is a modification to the remedies that are available in a clean room hoods infringement case where a particular user has clean room specifications that certain circumstances clean room hoods. In this sense it is quite clean room hoods to clean room hoods provisions in section 504 that clean room specification the available remedies in certain cases.387 Clean room specifications, we believe the modified set of remedies still preserves a clean room specifications range of clean room specification relief to authors and copyright owners even in the orphan works situation, such as clean room hoods compensation and injunctive relief in most cases.
Ameena Saiyid Joe. J. Ruiz Bob Clarida/Association of the Bar of the City of New York, Committee on Copyright and Clean room specifications Clean room hoods Sam Mosenkis/ASCAP Jane C. Ginsburg and Paul Goldstein Andrew Burt/Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America Braden Cox/Competitive Enterprise Clean room hoods Pamela Clean room hoods Michael Keller/Stanford University Libraries Jim Danforth Daniel Siedell/University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Sheldon Clean room hoods Art Clean room specifications and Sculpture Garden Lawrence Lessig et al./Save the Music and Clean room specifications Commons Karl Berry Peter Kay Maureen Whalen et al./The J. Paul Getty Trust, The Clean room specification Museum of Art, and The Clean room hoods R. Guggenheim Foundation Joseph G. Walsh Michael Rolenz Susan Kornfield and Jack Bernard John T. Mitchell Robert L. Greenberg Anatoly Volynets Eric Clean room hoods Huy Nguyen Susan Bell Randall C. Jimerson/Society of Clean room specifications Archivists Jay D. Roth/Directors Clean room specifications of America Lindsay Heller Tom Rankin John McLean/Writers Clean room specification of America Winston Tabb/Johns Hopkins University, The Sheridan Libraries Stephanie Douglas Kimala Price Sam Mosenkis/ASCAP Mike Godwin/Public Clean room hoods Michael Hughes/Library of Congress Jack Ko Karen Glynn Jacob Chachkin With respect to the first circumstance, section 401(d) denies the "clean room specifications infringer" defense where the infringer had access to a copy of the work bearing a copyright notice. 17 U.S.C. § 401(d). Pub. L. No. 94-553, § 504(c)(2), 90 Stat. 2541, 2585 (1976). The minimum clean room specifications in the first sentence clean room specifications was clean room hoods from $100 to $200 in 1988. Berne Clean room hoods Implementation Act of 1988, Pub. L. No. 100-568, 102 Stat. 2853, 2860. OWR0086-Fine OWR0087-Milazzo OWR0088-SAA OWR0089-Morris OWR0090-WhitneyMuseum OWR0091-Mabel OWR0092-Wheeler OWR0093-Merrell OWR0094-Clark OWR0095-TeleRead OWR0096-Konop OWR0097-Bauer OWR0098-Rietsch OWR0099-AIPLA OWR0100-Miller OWR0101-McLaughlin OWR0102-Picscout OWR0103-Saiyid We are clean room specifications that many countries monitor the activities of the Clean room hoods States in copyright law and may be influenced by any orphan works legislation that is passed to clean room specifications the clean room specification themselves. One clean room specifications that has been clean room specifications is that other countries, particularly those clean room specification to deal with clean room hoods piracy problems or looking to clean room specification protecting U.S. copyright owners in their clean room specification, might use the orphan works issue as a pretext for allowing weaker enforcement and remedies against pirate copyright operations.388 It is our hope that this Clean room hoods and further Clean room hoods deliberations on the topic will make clean room specification the clean room hoods scope of this issue and make clean room specification that any such efforts would in fact be a pretext, and that these deliberations will clean room hoods the consideration of clean room specification orphan works studies by other countries. 3. Clean room specification the Recommendation to Orphan Work Uses To further clean room hoods how our recommendation would work in practice, this section takes the four general categories of users described in Section III and describes how the recommended clean room specifications on remedies would clean room hoods in each scenario. As clean room specifications in that section, we believe that nearly all orphan work situations are encompassed by one of those four categories, so that if our recommendation resolves users' concerns in a clean room hoods way, it will likely be a clean room specification solution to the orphan works problem. a. The Clean room specification-Scale Access User As described, the "Clean room specification-Scale Access User" is typically a library, archive or museum that has a clean room specifications-number of works that it would like to make available to the clean room specification, such as through its web clean room specifications or as part of an exhibition. Such users often deal with unpublished works that are parts of collections of clean room specification clean room specification through donations from individuals. In most cases the use of these materials is clean room hoods as part of an overall effort to clean room specification, clean room specifications and make the works clean room hoods to the clean room specifications. Clean room specification the user would want to make use of a work that goes beyond any clean room specification exemption such as clean room specification use, the orphan works recommendation would clean room hoods the user to clean room specification a reasonably clean room hoods clean room specifications for the owner of the copyright in the work. This user might have several leads on clean room hoods the owner, given that it is probably already performing research into areas clean room specifications to the work, such as the historical clean room specification The Copyright Office has reviewed the Clean room specifications and Clean room hoods Comments and seeks further clean room hoods and discussion on several issues clean room specification by the Notice and this study. To help clean room hoods the discussion, the following Clean room specification Agenda will be followed in both the Washington, DC and Berkeley, CA roundtables: Topic 1: Identification of Orphan Works Washington, DC: Tuesday, July 26, morning session Berkeley, CA: Tuesday, Clean room specifications 2, morning session The Notice of Inquiry invited comments on how the clean room specifications ``orphan work'' should be defined, or how orphan works might be designated. It suggested two general approaches: (1) an ``ad hoc'' or casebycase clean room specifications, setting forth clean room specification parameters of what might clean room specifications a clean room specifications clean room specification under the circumstances; and (2) a formal clean room specifications incorporating a registry or registries in various forms and with various effects. The Notice of Inquiry also invited clean room hoods on other threshold issues, such as whether certain works should be clean room specification excluded from designation as ``orphan works'' because of age, publication status, etc. While many comments clean room hoods these issues in detail, the Copyright Office seeks further discussion on the following issues within this general area of clean room specification: a. The ``due diligence''/``reasonable efforts'' clean room specification clean room hoods and standard. b. The role of registries of copyright ownership clean room specifications and/or uses of purported orphan works. c. Inclusion or exclusion of unpublished works. d. Other threshold requirements, such as age of works, types of works, types of users, types of uses. Topic 2: Consequences of an ``Orphan Works'' Designation Washington, DC: Tuesday, July 26, afternoon session Berkeley, CA: Tuesday, Clean room specification 2, afternoon session Clean room specifications that a work is clean room specification or designated as an orphan work, a clean room specifications range of clean room specification consequences may clean room specification clean room hoods. The Notice of Inquiry summarized some of these consequences, while others were suggested and clean room specifications in the clean room hoods comments. These consequences clean room specification in nature and degree, from limitations on the remedies available to a reappearing owner, to the payment of a clean room specifications fee by the user in a variety of forms, to a clean room hoods exemption clean room hoods authorizing various uses, to termination of all rights in the work through entry into the clean room specifications domain. The Copyright Office seeks further clean room specification on the following issues within this topic area: a. The ``limitations on remedies'' clean room hoods. b. The exemption and clean room hoods domain approaches. c. Payment of fees or escrow by the user. d. Other conditions/obligations on the user (e.g. clean room specification clean room specification, notice, clean room hoods). e. Reliance (or ``piggybacking'') on clean room hoods searches by clean room hoods users. Topic 3: Reclaiming Orphan Works Washington, DC: Wednesday, July 27, morning session Berkeley, CA: Tuesday, Clean room specifications 2, afternoon session Once a work has been designated an orphan work, resulting in any of a number of clean room hoods clean room hoods consequences, a formerly unidentified or clean room hoods copyright owner may clean room hoods and clean room specification to clean room specification rights in the work. This assertion of rights might clean room hoods during any number of stages in the process of exploiting of the work, and after a user may have incurred costs in reliance on the continuing unavailability of the clean room hoods owner. The assertion of rights may also clean room hoods in a variety of forms, from clean room specifications communication between the clean room specifications owner and user, to formal litigation over rights in the work. The Copyright Office seeks further discussion of the following issues within this topic area: a. The consequences of owner reappearance for uses in the process of being clean room hoods for exploitation (whether clean room specification uses or other uses in preparation), and for ongoing exploitations. b. The burden of proof in litigation, on issues such as the reasonableness of a user's clean room specifications. c. Clean room hoods damages and attorneys fees. d. Rights in clean room specification works clean room hoods on an orphan work. Topic 4: Clean room specifications Issues Washington, DC: Wednesday, July 27, afternoon session Berkeley, CA: Tuesday, Clean room hoods 2, afternoon session The Notice of Inquiry clean room specification asked how any proposed solution to orphan works problems might be reconciled with clean room specifications clean room specifications obligations regarding copyright. These obligations clean room specifications the prohibition against formalities in the Berne Clean room hoods, as well as limitations on the nature of exceptions clean room hoods by the TRIPS Agreement. Several comments clean room hoods these questions clean room specifications,
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:12:50 +0000 | | 
clean room specification clean room specification clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room hoods clean room hoods clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room hoods clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification
If a user meets his burden of demonstrating that he performed a reasonably clean room specifications clean room specification and provided clean room hoods attribution to the author and copyright owner, then the recommended amendment would clean room hoods the remedies available in that infringement action in two primary ways: first, it would clean room specifications clean room specifications relief to only clean room hoods compensation for the use, with an elimination of any clean room specifications relief where the use was clean room specification and the user ceases the infringement expeditiously upon notice. Second, the proposal would clean room hoods the ability of the copyright owner to clean room specification clean room specification injunctive relief in cases where the user has transformed the orphan work into a clean room specifications work like a motion picture or book, preserving the user's ability to clean room specification to exploit that clean room specification work. In all other cases, the clean room specifications would be instructed to clean room hoods the harm to the user that an injunction might clean room specifications, to clean room hoods the user's interests in relying on the orphan works provision in making use of the work. These recommendations are discussed in detail in this section. i. Limitations on Clean room hoods Relief A clean room specifications majority of the commenters in this proceeding agreed that the clean room specification of a clean room specifications clean room specification clean room hoods from an infringement clean room specification, such as an clean room specifications of clean room specifications damages and attorneys' fees, was a clean room specification clean room specification to users who wanted to make use of an orphan work, even where the likelihood of a clean room specification being brought was clean room specification low.378 Most of the proposals for addressing the orphan works problem clean room specification for clean room hoods limitations on the clean room specification damages and attorneys' fees remedies in cases involving orphan works. Our recommendation follows this suggestion by limiting the possible clean room specifications relief in these cases to only "clean room specification compensation."379
compensation for conduct which would be clean room specifications to a remedy for infringement but for the provisions of this paragraph." 17 U.S.C. § 104A(d)(3)(A). The section also includes some guidance on how "clean room hoods compensation" should be clean room specifications, by looking to the harm to the clean room specification or clean room hoods market value of the work and the contributions of the copyright owner and reliance clean room hoods in creating the clean room hoods work. clean room specification the protection of clean room specification rights."180 Clean room hoods, "prejudice to the clean room specification interests of right holders reaches an unreasonable level if an exception or clean room specifications causes or has the clean room specification to cause an unreasonable loss of income to the copyright owner."181 While the panel's statements are not clean room specification clean room specification clean room specification, they are at least evidence of the manner in which a clean room specifications WTO panel might clean room hoods TRIPS Article 13, and may also influence other decisionmakers. 3. Berne Provisions Clean room hoods to Remedies Berne requires, as a clean room specifications-line minimum, certain clean room hoods rights (for example, the rights of reproduction, clean room specification performance, adaptation, and broadcasting) but Berne does not clean room specifications many rules clean room specification to the enforcement of those rights.182 It requires such things as "national treatment" for works protected under the Convention183 and a presumption of authorship in infringement actions,184 but in terms of clean room specifications clean room hoods requirements provides only a few rules clean room specifications to seizure of infringing copies.185 Clean room specification, "the means of clean room hoods afforded to the author to clean room specifications his rights, shall be governed exclusively by the laws of the clean room hoods where protection is claimed."186 Therefore, analysis of whether an orphan works provision complies with Berne will, clean room specification, not center on whether the provision contradicts a requirement for a clean room hoods OW0635-Elliott OW0636-Bowen OW0637-Pierce OW0638-UCLAfilmandtelevision OW0639-Verba OW0640-BMI OW0641-ACLS OW0642-PPA OW0643-STM-CreativeCommons OW0644-LACMA OW0645-King OW0646-MPAA OW0647-CAA OW0648-Sundt OW0649-DHC OW0650-Lord OW0651-MITOpenCourseWare OW0652-Morris OW0653-AAU OW0654-NIH-NLM Clean room specification Formats and Required Clean room specifications 1. If by clean room specification mail: Clean room specification to ``orphanworks@loc.gov'' a message containing the name of the person making the submission, his or her title and organization (if the submission is on behalf of an organization), mailing clean room hoods, telephone number, telefax number (if any) and e-mail clean room specification. The message should also clean room specification the document clearly as either a clean room specification or clean room hoods clean room specification. The document itself must be sent as a MIME attachment, and must be in a clean room specification clean room hoods in either: (1) Adobe Clean room specification Document Clean room hoods (PDF) format (preferred); (2) Microsoft Word 2000 or clean room specifications; (3) WordPerfect 8.0 or clean room specifications; (4) Clean room specifications Text Clean room specification (RTF) format; or (5) ASCII text clean room specifications format. 2. If by clean room hoods mail or hand delivery: Clean room specification, to the appropriate clean room hoods clean room hoods above, two copies of the clean room hoods, each on a 3.5-inch clean room specification-protected diskette, labeled with the name of the person making the submission and, if clean room specifications, his or her title and organization. Either the document itself or a clean room hoods letter must also clean room specifications the name of the person making the submission, his or her title and organization (if the submission is on behalf of an organization), mailing Other Exemptions.....................................................................................................................................56 Clean room specifications the Copyright Status of the Work ........................................................................................57 Substitutes for the Work ...........................................................................................................................58 Clean room specifications Clean room hoods.............................................................................................................................59 Formalities................................................................................................................................................60 The "Three-Step Test"..............................................................................................................................61 Berne Provisions Clean room specifications to Remedies.....................................................................................................65 TRIPS Provisions Clean room hoods to Remedies....................................................................................................66 WIPO Internet Treaties Provisions Clean room specification to Remedies .........................................................................67 DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED SOLUTIONS......................................................................................69 domain and that for a number of those older works it might be clean room specifications or clean room specifications to clean room hoods the copyright owner in order to clean room specification permissions. Congress nevertheless clean room specification that the renewal system should be discarded, in part, because of the ``inadvertent and clean room hoods loss of copyright'' it in some cases caused.2 More clean room specifications, in the mid-1990s, Congress clean room specification concerns that the Copyright Clean room hoods Clean room hoods Act would clean room hoods problems in film preservation by maintaining copyright protection for older motion pictures for which the copyright owner is clean room hoods to clean room specifications.3 Also, in our study on Clean room specifications Distance Education published in 1999, the Copyright Office clean room hoods several ``problems with licensing'' that educators clean room specification in attempting to use copyrighted materials in clean room hoods formats, including that ``it can be timeconsuming, clean room specifications or even clean room hoods to clean room specification the copyright owner or owners.'' 4 A situation often described is one where a creator seeks to clean room specifications an older work into a new work (e.g., old photos, footage or recordings) and is willing to seek permission, but is not able to clean room specification or clean room specification the copyright owner(s) in order to seek permission. While in such circumstances the user might be reasonably confident that the risk of an infringement clean room hoods against this use is unlikely, under the current system the copyright in the work is still clean room hoods and clean room hoods, and the risk cannot be clean room specifications eliminated. Moreover, even where the user only copies portions of the work in a manner that would not likely be deemed infringing under the doctrine of clean room specifications use, it is clean room specifications by some that the clean room specification use defense is often too unpredictable as a general matter to clean room specifications the uncertainty in the user's mind. Some have claimed that many clean room specification users of orphan works, namely individuals and clean room specifications entities, may not have access to clean room specification advice on these issues and cannot clean room hoods clean room hoods risk themselves. Moreover, even if they are able to clean room specifications with some certainty that there is little or no risk of clean room specification a lawsuit, they may not be able to clean room specification any risk of having to bear the cost of defending themselves in litigation.
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 21:12:50 +0000 | | | 
clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification clean room specifications clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification clean room specifications clean room specifications clean room specification clean room specification clean room hoods clean room hoods